In a move that stunned fans and analysts alike, New York Mets manager Carlos Mendoza made a highly controversial pitching decision during a recent game against the Washington Nationals that has since set social media ablaze and reignited debate over his bullpen management. With the Mets leading 6-0 and starting pitcher Tylor Megill cruising through six dominant innings—allowing just one hit and striking out nine—Mendoza opted to pull Megill from the game. The unexpected substitution left many scratching their heads, wondering why Mendoza would remove a pitcher who was not only dealing but clearly in control of the game.
The decision quickly backfired. José Buttó, brought in to relieve Megill, struggled to find his rhythm. He surrendered a three-run home run to Nationals catcher Riley Adams, suddenly cutting the Mets’ comfortable lead in half. With momentum shifting, Mendoza turned to Ryne Stanek to close out the game in the ninth inning. However, Stanek—who had blown a save opportunity just one game prior—was again unable to deliver. He allowed the Nationals to tie the game before a throwing error by first baseman Pete Alonso led to a walk-off loss for the Mets.
The fallout was immediate and intense. Fans lit up social media with criticism, questioning Mendoza’s decision-making and calling it one of the most baffling managerial moves of the season so far. Sports radio lines buzzed with angry callers, and even analysts on TV struggled to make sense of the strategy. Many argued that Mendoza should have let Megill continue pitching, at least into the seventh or eighth inning, given his dominance on the mound and the cushion the Mets held on the scoreboard.
This isn’t the first time Mendoza’s bullpen usage has come under fire. Since taking over as Mets manager, he’s made several high-risk pitching calls that have yielded mixed results. Supporters say he’s playing the matchups and trying to protect his starters’ arms over the long haul, especially in a season where postseason ambitions are high. Critics, however, see a pattern of over-managing and unnecessarily pulling effective pitchers, which they argue is costing the team winnable games.
Adding fuel to the fire is the recent inconsistency of the Mets’ bullpen. Once considered a strength of the team, recent performances have raised concerns about reliability under pressure. Ryne Stanek’s back-to-back blown saves have particularly drawn scrutiny, and some are beginning to question his role as the go-to closer.
As the Mets try to stay competitive in the crowded NL East, Mendoza’s decision-making will undoubtedly remain under the microscope. With a passionate fanbase and a high-expectation front office, the margin for error is razor thin. Whether Mendoza’s bold choices will pay off in the long run remains to be seen, but for now, his latest pitching change has become the talk of the baseball world—and not in a good way.
Would you like this formatted as an article or blog post?
