Browns Shock the NFL: Myles Garrett’s Extension Leads to Surprise QB Pick in First Round
The Cleveland Browns sent shockwaves through the NFL with their first-round pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, selecting a quarterback despite having Deshaun Watson under contract. The decision comes just days after the franchise signed defensive superstar Myles Garrett to a record-breaking contract extension, raising questions about the team’s long-term vision and commitment to their current quarterback situation.
Garrett’s Landmark Deal and Its Implications
Garrett’s extension, reportedly worth over $150 million with a substantial guaranteed portion, cements his role as the cornerstone of Cleveland’s defense for years to come. The 28-year-old pass rusher has been the heart and soul of the Browns’ defense, consistently ranking among the league’s top edge rushers. By locking up Garrett, Cleveland has ensured stability on that side of the ball. However, this massive financial commitment means the team will need to be strategic about managing its salary cap moving forward.
With Watson’s fully guaranteed five-year, $230 million contract still looming, the Browns’ front office was already facing financial constraints. While some expected the team to prioritize offensive line help or another weapon for Watson, the decision to draft a quarterback suggests deeper concerns about the position’s long-term stability.
A Lack of Faith in Watson?
Deshaun Watson’s tenure in Cleveland has been marked by inconsistency and injuries. After serving an 11-game suspension in 2022, he struggled to regain the elite form he displayed in Houston. Over the past two seasons, his performance has fluctuated, with flashes of brilliance overshadowed by erratic decision-making and injury setbacks. In 2024, he missed significant time due to a shoulder issue, raising concerns about his durability.
By selecting [insert QB’s name] in the first round, the Browns are signaling that they may not be entirely sold on Watson as their long-term answer. The new rookie could be viewed as a developmental project, but he also provides an insurance policy should Watson’s struggles continue.
Strategic Roster Building or Overreaction?
Cleveland’s front office, led by General Manager Andrew Berry, has consistently taken an aggressive approach to roster construction. From trading for Watson to extending Garrett and other core players, the Browns have demonstrated a win-now mentality. However, using a premium draft pick on a quarterback instead of addressing other immediate needs has sparked debate.
Some analysts believe this move reflects smart roster management, ensuring that the team has a young quarterback waiting in the wings in case Watson fails to meet expectations. Others argue that Cleveland should have used the pick to fortify the offensive line or secondary, two areas that could use reinforcements.
What’s Next for the Browns?
This decision sets up a fascinating dynamic in Cleveland. If Watson plays well and remains healthy, the rookie may remain on the bench for the foreseeable future. However, if Watson continues to struggle, the pressure to turn to the new quarterback could intensify quickly.
One thing is certain: the Browns aren’t content with standing still. By extending Garrett and drafting a quarterback in the first round, they have made it clear that they are planning for both the present and the future. Whether this gamble pays off remains to be seen.
