In a surprising legal move, Penn State’s head football coach James Franklin has initiated a $400 million lawsuit against both the NCAA and Pennsylvania State University. The complaint, submitted on Friday in State College, alleges a “coordinated effort” between the NCAA and university officials aiming to tarnish Franklin’s reputation via false investigations, strategic media leaks, and internal tactics designed to force him out of his position.
Franklin’s legal team points to mounting tension between the school and the NCAA following Penn State’s strong performances under his leadership—including a Big Ten title and multiple College Football Playoff appearances. The lawsuit contends that the NCAA interfered in internal program matters by launching premature enforcement actions based on “unsubstantiated” infractions, creating a hostile working environment, breaching his contractual protections, and attempting to sabotage his tenure.
The NCAA and Penn State’s athletic department have not issued public comments yet. However, sources within the school administration indicate concern and are reportedly preparing formal responses. It’s expected that a highly organized PR and legal strategy will follow from both sides.
Since taking over in 2014, Franklin has compiled a 101–42 record, secured the 2016 Big Ten championship, and steadily rebuilt the program post-sanctions . He also recently strengthened his staff by hiring Jim Knowles as defensive coordinator, a move highlighted as “a twisting, turning process” from Franklin himself .
Experts say this lawsuit could fundamentally alter NCAA oversight procedures and influence future coach-university power dynamics. With Franklin alleging defamation and contract breach, the case may set a precedent for how far governing bodies can go in scrutinizing major programs.
