In a stunning and unexpected move, the Baltimore Ravens have signed undrafted kicker John Hoyland from the University of Wyoming, just days after the team released longtime veteran and NFL icon Justin Tucker. The news has sent shockwaves throughout the NFL community, not only because of Tucker’s reputation as arguably the greatest kicker in league history, but also due to the circumstances surrounding his release.
Hoyland earned his opportunity after an impressive showing during the Ravens’ rookie minicamp. Coming off a solid 2024 season in which he connected on 15 of 19 field goal attempts and was perfect on extra points, Hoyland has shown the potential to step into a high-pressure role quickly. He now joins sixth-round draft pick Tyler Loop from the University of Arizona as the leading candidates to fill the massive void left by Tucker.
Justin Tucker’s departure from the team on May 5 was officially labeled a “football decision” by the Ravens’ front office, but the timing has raised eyebrows across the league. Tucker is currently the subject of an NFL investigation following allegations of sexual misconduct involving 16 women. While no formal charges have been filed at this time, the nature of the accusations and the gravity of the investigation have led to speculation that the team sought to distance itself from any potential scandal.
Tucker, a University of Texas alumnus, had been the Ravens’ kicker since 2012. Over his illustrious career, he earned multiple All-Pro honors and was known for his consistency, clutch performances, and unmatched range. He holds numerous NFL records, including the longest made field goal in league history at 66 yards. For the Ravens, replacing him is not just a question of performance—it’s about finding someone capable of handling the intense scrutiny and pressure that come with the position.
The organization’s decision to go with two young, unproven kickers underscores its long-standing commitment to developing talent internally. The Ravens have a history of turning undrafted kickers into Pro Bowlers, including Tucker himself, along with Graham Gano and Wil Lutz. Special teams coach Randy Brown, widely respected for his ability to evaluate and mentor specialists, will play a pivotal role in shaping the competition and guiding the team through this transitional period.
Public and fan reaction has been mixed. Some have expressed disappointment over Tucker’s release and the unclear messaging from the Ravens’ leadership. Others have praised the team for taking a proactive stance amid the troubling allegations, regardless of the fallout. Meanwhile, some fans have speculated about potential suitors for Tucker, should he be cleared of wrongdoing and choose to continue his career elsewhere.
As it stands, the Ravens are entering the 2025 season with uncertainty at one of football’s most critical specialist roles. Whether Hoyland or Loop emerges as the long-term answer remains to be seen. What is clear, however, is that the Ravens are turning the page on one of the most stable eras of kicking in NFL history—and starting a new chapter defined by risk, competition, and redemption.
