There is currently no confirmed trade between the Dodgers and Cardinals involving Arenado. While the idea of Arenado in Dodger blue is an exciting one for fans—and something that has been speculated on for years—it remains just that: speculation. As of early May 2025, the Dodgers’ front office has publicly reaffirmed their commitment to Max Muncy as the team’s starting third baseman.
Muncy, who has been with the Dodgers since 2018, recently signed a two-year contract extension in 2023. Though he struggled with consistency at the plate last season, the team values his power, versatility, and leadership. When asked about the persistent Arenado trade rumors, Muncy addressed them diplomatically, stating that he would welcome any move that improves the team, even if it meant changing his own role. That quote—meant to show team-first humility—has since been misrepresented in some media circles as a “shocking admission” or even a signal of his impending departure, neither of which is accurate.
Nolan Arenado, meanwhile, remains under contract with the Cardinals and has a full no-trade clause, which he has reportedly used in the past to block potential moves, including one to the Houston Astros. While the Cardinals are in a period of retooling and could entertain trade offers, Arenado has not indicated that he wants out of St. Louis. Moreover, moving his large contract—he’s owed over $100 million through 2027—would require significant financial maneuvering.
From the Dodgers’ perspective, acquiring Arenado would undoubtedly bolster an already potent roster. A career .287 hitter with 10 Gold Gloves and 5 Platinum Gloves, Arenado is one of the premier defensive players of his generation. Pairing him with stars like Mookie Betts, Freddie Freeman, and Shohei Ohtani would make Los Angeles even more formidable in their quest for another World Series title. But given the team’s current infield setup and luxury tax considerations, such a deal is far from imminent.
In conclusion, while it’s fun to imagine Arenado anchoring third base for the Dodgers, fans should temper their expectations. As of now, Max Muncy remains the team’s third baseman, and no trade for Nolan Arenado has taken place. The Dodgers are known for making splashy moves, but this particular headline appears to be more fiction than fact.
Would you like updates if this situation changes during the season?
