Jordan Romano’s current 7.24 ERA after giving up a grand slam tonight highlights a concerning period of poor performance for the Phillies’ bullpen. As a reliever, especially one who is expected to handle high-leverage situations, such struggles can significantly impact the team’s chances in close games. The Phillies now face a critical decision on how best to manage Romano to protect both the team’s competitiveness and his long-term development.
First, it’s important to consider Romano’s recent performance beyond just the ERA. ERA can sometimes be misleading for relievers due to small sample sizes and the volatility of inherited runners scoring. However, a 7.24 ERA suggests there are underlying issues, whether mechanical, mental, or strategic. Giving up a grand slam in a key moment further magnifies the problem, as it directly costs runs and momentum.
Option 1: Send Romano to the Minors
One of the most straightforward options is to temporarily option Romano to the minors if he has minor league options remaining. This would allow him to work on specific issues away from the pressure of major league games. In the minors, he could focus on refining his mechanics, improving his command, and regaining confidence by facing less formidable hitters. This approach is common for relievers who show signs of command struggles or mechanical inconsistencies. A stint in the minors could help him reset mentally and physically, preparing him to return stronger.
Option 2: Pitching Coach and Analytical Adjustments
Alternatively, the Phillies could keep Romano on the roster but have him work closely with the pitching coach and analysts to identify what’s gone wrong. Sometimes poor results stem from changes in pitch location, velocity, or sequencing. If data reveals that hitters are sitting on certain pitches or that Romano’s release point has altered, coaching interventions can be tailored accordingly. This approach keeps Romano in the majors but aims to fix issues before they worsen. It’s especially viable if Romano’s struggles stem from a minor mechanical flaw rather than a loss of overall ability.
Option 3: Adjust Usage and Workload
Another strategy is to manage Romano’s workload more carefully. Relievers can suffer mentally and physically from overuse or high-leverage pressure. Reducing his innings or avoiding tough matchups temporarily might ease the pressure and help him regain composure. For example, the Phillies could limit Romano to low-leverage innings, allowing him to rebuild confidence without the weight of critical situations. This might not fix the underlying issue but could prevent further damage while other solutions are pursued.
Option 4: Bullpen Reshuffling
Lastly, the Phillies could reconfigure the bullpen roles, moving Romano out of closer or setup duties to middle relief, where the stakes are lower. This can take some pressure off and allow other pitchers with better recent performance to handle the critical innings. It also signals to Romano that his current struggles are being taken seriously but that the team still values him enough to keep him involved.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the best course for the Phillies depends on what their internal evaluations reveal about Romano’s struggles. If it’s a temporary mechanical or confidence issue, a short trip to the minors combined with focused coaching may be ideal. If it’s more about mental fatigue or workload, usage adjustments could help. The Phillies’ goal will be to preserve Romano’s long-term value while protecting the bullpen’s overall effectiveness.
Given the high stakes in the bullpen, the Phillies cannot afford to let these struggles continue unchecked. Addressing Romano’s issues quickly will be crucial for both his development and the team’s success going forward.