Deshaun Watson’s tenure with the Cleveland Browns appears to be nearing its end, marking a significant and somber development in the NFL community. Once heralded as a franchise quarterback, Watson’s journey in Cleveland has been fraught with challenges, both on and off the field.
In October 2024, Watson suffered a torn Achilles tendon during a game against the Cincinnati Bengals, sidelining him for the remainder of the season. This injury was particularly devastating as it marked his second Achilles tear in just 12 weeks. Subsequently, in January 2025, he underwent a second surgery to repair the re-ruptured tendon, casting doubt on his availability for the entire 2025 season .
The Browns’ management has been candid about the situation. General Manager Andrew Berry acknowledged the uncertainty surrounding Watson’s return, stating that while nothing is definitive, the outlook is bleak . Head Coach Kevin Stefanski noted that Watson is out of his walking boot and progressing in rehab, but no clear timeline for his return has been established .
Financially, the Browns are exploring options to mitigate the impact of Watson’s contract. The team could potentially recoup up to $60 million through insurance if Watson misses the entire 2025 season . This would provide some relief from the $230 million fully guaranteed contract that has become a significant burden on the team’s salary cap.
The Browns’ quarterback room has undergone significant changes in response to Watson’s uncertain status. Veteran Joe Flacco, along with Kenny Pickett, has been brought in to provide stability. Additionally, the team drafted Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders, both of whom are competing for roster spots. Analysts have noted that Gabriel has shown promise, while Sanders is praised for his NFL-caliber skills .
Public sentiment has also shifted. Browns co-owner Jimmy Haslam admitted that the decision to acquire Watson was a “big swing and miss,” acknowledging the trade’s failure to meet expectations . This sentiment is echoed by fans and analysts alike, many of whom believe that Watson’s time in Cleveland is effectively over.
As the Browns prepare for the 2025 season, the focus is on rebuilding and moving forward. The team is exploring new quarterback options and seeking to rectify past missteps. While Watson’s future in the NFL remains uncertain, the Browns are taking steps to ensure the team’s long-term success.
