Phillies Rumored to Target $100 Million Twins All-Star Byron Buxton in Controversial Potential Deal
The MLB world is abuzz with speculation following reports that the Philadelphia Phillies are eyeing Minnesota Twins outfielder Byron Buxton ahead of the 2025 trade deadline. The potential move has stirred strong reactions across the baseball community, with some calling it a bold gamble and others labeling it a disastrous idea that could backfire for Philadelphia.
Byron Buxton, a former All-Star and Gold Glove winner, is one of the most dynamic players in the game when healthy. His combination of speed, power, and elite defensive prowess in center field makes him a rare talent. However, Buxton has long been plagued by injuries that have prevented him from maintaining consistent on-field performance. Despite signing a $100 million contract extension with the Twins in late 2021, Buxton has struggled to stay on the field, appearing in just 85 games in 2023 and 97 in 2024.
The Phillies are reportedly looking to upgrade their center field situation, where current starter Brandon Marsh has provided solid but unspectacular play. While Marsh has improved offensively, many in the organization view him as better suited to a corner outfield role. Buxton, at his best, would represent a significant upgrade in terms of both defense and power potential.
Yet, the idea of acquiring Buxton has many Phillies fans on edge. The primary concern is his health. Buxton’s extensive injury history includes hip, knee, and shoulder issues, raising doubts about his ability to contribute down the stretch and into a potential playoff run. Committing to a player with such a track record—especially one still owed over $45 million through 2028—is viewed by critics as a high-risk, potentially low-reward move.
Moreover, the cost in terms of prospects or young major league talent could be substantial. The Twins are still in the mix for a postseason spot and would demand significant value in return, especially for a player with Buxton’s ceiling. For a Phillies farm system that’s already been depleted by recent trades, giving up additional young talent could hurt the organization long-term.
Supporters of the move argue that Buxton could be a game-changer for Philadelphia. If he manages to stay healthy, his impact on both offense and defense could push the Phillies over the top in a tightly contested National League playoff race. His speed and range in the outfield would help shore up a defense that has been shaky at times, while his bat could slot into the middle of a potent lineup that includes Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, and Kyle Schwarber.
Ultimately, the rumored pursuit of Byron Buxton is emblematic of the tightrope that contending teams walk during trade season. The Phillies must weigh the upside of acquiring a player with elite tools against the very real risks posed by his injury history and financial commitment. Whether this deal materializes or not, it’s clear that Philadelphia is exploring all options to maximize its championship window—no matter how controversial they may be.
