Deshaun Watson’s tumultuous tenure with the Cleveland Browns has officially come to an end, marking a somber chapter in recent NFL history. Once hailed as a franchise-altering acquisition, Watson’s time in Cleveland was marred by controversy, injury, and unmet expectations—culminating in his confirmed departure from the team.
Watson was traded to the Browns in 2022 from the Houston Texans and signed a fully guaranteed $230 million contract, the most lucrative deal in NFL history at the time. The Browns believed they were investing in an elite quarterback capable of elevating the franchise. However, almost immediately, Watson’s career in Cleveland began on shaky ground. He was suspended for 11 games in the 2022 season after more than two dozen women accused him of sexual misconduct during massage sessions. The NFL’s investigation led to a settlement that included the suspension, a $5 million fine, and mandatory behavioral therapy.
Though Watson returned to the field late in 2022, his performances were inconsistent. The Browns hoped that a full offseason and training camp would return Watson to his Pro Bowl form. Yet, in 2023 and 2024, his gameplay failed to match the expectations that came with his massive contract. The low point came in October 2024 when Watson tore his Achilles tendon during a matchup against the Cincinnati Bengals. The season-ending injury was a major setback, and although surgery was initially successful, he suffered a re-rupture in January 2025 during rehabilitation.
This re-injury raised serious concerns about Watson’s long-term durability and viability as a starting quarterback. The Browns were left with little choice but to consider moving on, particularly given the financial strain. Fortunately for Cleveland, a little-known insurance clause in Watson’s contract was activated due to his prolonged injury-related absence. That clause could allow the team to recoup as much as $60 million, easing the financial burden of his guaranteed deal.
In the wake of Watson’s final departure, Browns owner Jimmy Haslam publicly acknowledged the move as a “big swing and miss.” He admitted that the organization took a significant risk that ultimately didn’t pay off. This candid admission underscores the magnitude of the failed investment and the ripple effects it has had on the team’s planning and reputation.
Now, the Browns are focused on the future, looking to rebuild their quarterback room and recalibrate their approach to roster construction. They are expected to explore the draft, free agency, and potential trades as they seek a more stable and reliable presence under center.
For the broader NFL community, Watson’s story is a cautionary tale about high-stakes deals, character concerns, and the unpredictable nature of injuries in professional sports. Once seen as one of the league’s most promising quarterbacks, Watson’s fall from grace is a sobering reminder that talent alone does not guarantee success—or redemption.
Would you like a timeline of Deshaun Watson’s time with the Browns?
